|

Editorial terminology

Use the right words to prevent client confusion

The other day I saw a writer upset that their editor promised several passes through their manuscript but in fact only did one. It was a classic case of miscommunication of editorial terminology.

What the writer expected was for the editor to provide feedback through several revisions. What the writer got was just one edit, one time. 

It turned out that the writer didn’t understand what an editorial pass is. It is not the same thing as “an edit” or an editorial round. 

If you’re working with indie authors you cannot expect them to immediately know and understand editorial terminology, especially when editors sometimes use the terms loosely themselves and when different words are used to mean the same thing (is it developmental editing, story editing, content editing, substantive editing? It can be called all of those things).

But editorial passes and editorial rounds are two different things. When you use these terms, though, you need to be crystal clear what you mean by them.

Editorial round vs editorial pass

An “editorial round” is one complete edit. In development, this consists of editorial queries on the ms itself and a revision letter (sometimes called an editorial letter). 

A ms may require more than one round of development. This would be what the writer above was envisioning, where the dev editor would review the writer’s revision and make additional edits. Typically this is necessary when the ms is in poor shape and needs a lot of work.

In traditional publishing, manuscripts typically go through several rounds of editing of different types, including a development round, a copyediting round, and a proofing round.

An “editorial pass” is the editor going through the ms one time, addressing errors. Most editors take several passes through a ms to complete one editorial round. That’s likely what this editor told the writer: “I’ll take several passes through your ms.”

The writer understood this to mean “rounds” when the editor merely meant they were going to be thorough in the edit.

A “revision round” is the author revising the ms completely in response to an editorial round. Like an editor, authors may take several passes through the ms in order to complete the round. When the author feels they’ve addressed the concerns to the best of their ability, the revision round is complete.

Define editorial terminology when working with authors

Make sure you clearly define the deliverables of your edit, use terminology carefully (and explain what it means!), and you’re less likely to encounter a problem like this one.


Other Helpful Content

  • Avoiding Scope Creep

    Whether you’re a developmental editor, a copyeditor, or a line editor, avoiding scope creep helps you hit deadlines and build a successful business. Avoiding Scope Creep for Editors When we edit novels, much of our work involves evaluating the problems in the manuscript and suggesting possible revisions for the author. If Joe’s character motivation needs…

    Read more…

  • The Beauty of Boundaries

    Finding the right clients for your freelance editing business is crucial. A great way to do this is by setting boundaries: “Yes, I do this; no, I don’t do that.” Boundaries help make it perfectly clear to a client or prospective client what working with you is like. You can have different boundaries from me,…

    Read more…

  • Give Yourself a Few Kind Words

    I often hear from newer editors who are feeling a little doubtful. They experience imposter syndrome and second-guess themselves. This can make it difficult for them to market or to feel confident in raising prices – in short, they struggle to run a successful business because they’re not sure of their skills. It may not…

    Read more…

Join the Club!

New to story editing? Begin at the beginning.

Similar Posts