How to be a Novel Editor
Are you seeking direction on how to be a novel editor?
For those who love words, the question of how to become a novel editor can be an exciting start or an overwhelming obstacle. Here I share some tips on how to make it happen!
I quit smoking more than twenty years ago. This doesn’t make me an expert on dealing with addiction.
I broke my ankle last July and have recovered full function since then. This doesn’t make me an expert in physical therapy.
But I am an expert in storytelling and in editing works of fiction. Yes, I wrote some novels that were published by traditional publishers.

But I also have Ph.D in English literature, for which I studied how stories work; I have countless hours of professional development as a writer and editor (including classes, workshops, conferences, and more); I have been taught by mentors on the job for many years; I have watched and experienced how other editors work; I have networked with hundreds of colleagues to understand how they work and to identify best practices; I read and critique dozens of stories/novels a year to identify how they work (or how they don’t); I listen carefully to the feedback of students and clients; and, most important of all, I am willing to adjust what I know when I encounter new information.
That’s how you develop expertise in a subject matter.
Personal experience is always a great place to start (for example, you’ve written a novel or you had a manuscript edited) but it’s not the end. It’s the first step.
If you want to move beyond your own personal experience to understand how to edit for others, the self-paced package of classes, DE 1 – 6, is a great place to start.
Other Helpful Content
-
Reading Books for a Living
I discourage editors from saying that our work is “reading books for a living” because that diminishes our expertise and experience. Editing is not reading books for a living; it’s understanding stories and storytelling techniques, cultivating judgment and discernment, practicing effective editorial methodologies and more. But some days, like today, I look around my office…
-
What Makes an Expert Editor?
Doing something for a long time does not equal expertise. I’ve been singing in the shower for years, but you would not want my tips on training your vocal cords. For years I cut my daughter’s bangs. But you don’t want me touching your hair. Experience versus Expertise I’ve met a lot of freelancers over…
-
Learning How to Edit
I’m learning how to speak Spanish, and sometimes I get discouraged because it takes a while. (This is not unlike learning any important skill). One of the most helpful bits of perspective-taking I do is to consider whether I encounter the same problems when speaking in English. For example, people often interrupt me to finish…
Join the Club!
New to story editing? Begin at the beginning.



