When Is a Book Ready for Editing?
Both authors and editors have the same question at some point in the book writing / publishing process: When is a book ready for editing?
So When IS a Book Ready for Editing?
The creative process is not timely and linear, which is why, as an editor, I don’t book edits before an author’s manuscript is finished, though I will book coaching when an author is stalled and needs to do some brainstorming and problem-solving.
I implemented this policy after the tenth or twelfth writer who had booked an edit said something like, “I know the ending is rushed” or “I know Josiah needs a stronger character arc,” but “I didn’t want to miss the deadline to send this to you.”
The thing is, if the author already knows the ending is rushed and Josiah needs a stronger character arc, what is this manuscript doing in my inbox? The author should address what they know are the problems.
I come in – or at least I should come in – once the author has done all he or she knows how to do to polish the story. I’m the second pair of eyes that helps them see what they can’t. They don’t need me to see what they already see.
Most writers, including me, have day jobs and family obligations, and sometimes these get in the way of our ability to do the work in a timely fashion. But even for writers who adhere to a strict schedule, any particular project may or may not cooperate.
Let the Process Drive the Deadline
Most of us would do better to let the process drive the deadline and not the other way around. If it will take a few more weeks to figure out Josiah’s character arc, then let it take a few more weeks.
That’s not to say that you shouldn’t try to meet a deadline; sometimes, a deadline is what keeps our attention on a particular project. I’m just saying that we also have to respect the process: if the manuscript isn’t ready on Tuesday the 15th, it’s not ready. Trying to pretend it is doesn’t do the work justice.
If you’re hustling to meet a deadline and overlooking issues you know exist, take a step back. Let the process have a say.
Tips for Editors & Writers
Introducing: Editing Horror
I’ve edited a fair amount of fiction over the years, but I’ve never edited horror. I’m not a horror reader and I don’t understand the genre. But ever since I started teaching at Club Ed, I’ve wanted to add a horror class because I know it’s a hugely popular genre and it feels like a…
More Powerful than AI
AI is going to kill routine jobs. But it won’t kill jobs that require expertise and human judgment. That’s why it’s important for editors to move beyond basic skills like proofreading. It’s not enough to say, “But homophones!” Most people will accept a small error rate if it means they can save three thousand dollars….
Book Editing Tip: Less Is More
My best book editing tip is just three words: Less is more. The deliverables for a developmental edit are (1) an edited manuscript and (2) a revision letter. It doesn’t get any more basic than that! A Simple Book Editing Tip – Less is More That’s it. Sometimes newer editors also add charts, spreadsheets, color…
